109
J –
=
" #
$ *>, ; "? # * $, " !
# !
$ )
"
+ ")C"
??)'" ! "#)#" ! # )
$"? " : ,>+ " $" $ " "C $, (# *-
')
. _ ;# ! * " & (
$$"*)E"! ! * ! !" &
;#
D , "
!"* !
$,* ! # ) ! # +"!") ! ( +*:# ( " 8 +$)-
"
$
(! # )
+" (! " $)E ! #,C" # ! #* ?$ ! -
! !
&# !" "#
C&
#"* (), ( ) ") !
$
$ $
(;
$D ) * ! !" & ;# D " $# *") 8& " ! # *'
!
$
! (
>(
) (.
$") ! $
> > "*:! $ # (
")-
! , "# !&
$ $
> >
;
, # )! # !& "
" : "
$#"* ")"! ! "'& : «")
( ! *) (
$" ! + & $& $
#*;'" "' *!&!
C* (
; (
+ : »; #; ! ! ( >( -
) ( ( #"*
>*; ! & $ () ") ! ! ") ( ! .
$ +"! $ , # ,C" & " # +"), ! ( ;C ! !; , !$&-
$ ! (, # ,C"! ! ') ! + & . ! ( +"!
) (, & * "! ) (-
!: , #* ) (
$"?; $ ) ! + &, , !
" # !" ( !
# !& "
> *$ ?& ! . $ ) # ( +"! !, # ) ( ! + & > )-
"!
$, # ! )
! 8 8 ) ! (
Hart,
The Concept of Law
, # ( # * !)-
+" ! !*" ? $ ) ! + & : ( ) + & &! #; ! !" # " !& #
!
$ (
, # )!" ).
= $ ) ?) "! # * " !
# " ! !
+ & ")C"
,
C" * !
) . (8) "; " "
> *$ +") + & " ;-
# " #"* #!: " #* #! ( ! !*
> , ( ,#" " ? !
) . (?)
+ & ,C" ! $ ) ! #
> ) "! $, # , (? " * $, # -
*; " ?
$ , , ;! $ +( ;E" #* # C*
$ C+ ? ! "#)!"('
" # !,* (
+
# .
2.
!" #
$%& '*+ /0 3$4 Lon Fuller
!
Harvard Law School,
+ ? !& " &
!"
?)
>) ! ( = ) (, Fuller, ,#!('" $ " ;$" C & ,D" # (
$; + "
$ *> $, & !* # # $, $ +"! $ (qual-
ified legal positivism). ,#!('" ;# * !&* + & ! # ) #*,#"
" (#;*
C ( ! $ .
+ & (!& !
$ " " !"* & + & & + &
" (#;*
C ( ! $ (morality immanent in the law). + & ! ( C * -
! *)
+ "
! &
+ &, * 8:
! "
$#"* ,C" * $, "
-
! , *
C, &
! &
> "
" # ( #*,#" ,# ( ! )-
.