ŎŐňŎŇńŒņőņ Łōňőņő Ł¨ňʼnŁňŎŊŎŃņŒŎœ ŏŊŎœŒňőŋŎœ őŒŎ ńŊŊņŌňʼnŎ & őŒŎ ŁŃŃŊňʼnŎ ¨ňʼnŁňŎ
37
ŬŜŮůŤŧŢ ŬŷŮűŞůŞ
184
, šŦŞŦŮůŹũūũůŞŦ ŢŦŧŞŨŸųŢŦŭ Ţ řŨŨŞ ŢšŜŞ ůūŰ šŦ-
ŧŞŜūŰ. œřŬŲūŰũ ŢŜŮŤŭ, ŨŷŠūŦ ūŰ ŮŲŢůŜţūũůŞŦ Ţ ůŤũ ŞűŜşūŨŤ ŞūůŢ-
ŨŢŮŞůŦŧŷůŤůŞ ūŰ ŚŲŢŦ Ť ũūūťŢŮŜŞ Ůůū common law, ŧŞťŹŭ űŞŜũŢůŞŦ
ŷůŦ ťŚůŢŦ ŮŢ ŧŜũšŰũū ůŤũ ůŢŲũŦŧś ůŤŭ ŢŰŚŨŦŧůŤŭ ŢŦŨūŠśŭ šŦŧŞŜūŰ ŧŞŦ ůŤŭ
ŞũřůŰŪŤŭ ŚŮŴ ůŤŭ ŢŢŦŬŜŞŭ ŠŦŞ ůūũ ůŬŷū ŨŢŦůūŰŬŠŜŞŭ ŦŞŭ ŞŬŲśŭ
185
.
Ŏ ŨŷŬšūŭ Reid ŮŢ ūŦŨŜŞ ůūŰ ŞũŚűŢŬŢ
186
: «Łũ ŮŧŚűůŢŮůŢ Ţ ŬūūůŦŧś
ŤũŹũ, ŞũŞţŤůŢŜůŢ ŦŞ ŮůŦŠŦŞŜŞ ŨŸŮŤ ŮůŞ ŬūşŨśŞůř ŮŞŭ ŧŞŦ šŢũ ŮŞŭ
ŢũšŦŞűŚŬŢŦ Ţřũ ťŞ ŬūŮŞŬūŮůŢŜ ūŬťŹŭ, ŮůūŲŢŸŮůŢ ŮůŤ ũūūťŢŮŜŞ. Łũ
ŮŧŚűůŢŮůŢ Ţ ŬūūůŦŧś šŢŧŞŢůŦŹũ, ŬūůŦřůŢ ůŤ ŢťūšŦŧś ŞũřůŰŪŤ
ŧŞŦ ŦŮůŢŸŢůŢ ŮůŤũ ŞŨŦř ŞŬūŦŜŞ «ŢŬŦŮŮŷůŢŬŤ ŮūŰšś, ŨŦŠŷůŢŬŤ ůŞ-
ŲŸůŤůŞ», ůŷůŢ ŞŬŞŢŜũŞůŢ ŦŮůūŜ Ůůū common law». ŋŦŞ ŞŧŷŞ ŧŬŦůŦŧś
ŠŦŞ ůŤ ũūūťŢŮŜŞ ŞūůŢŨŢŜ Ť ůřŮŤ ůŴũ ŮŸŠŲŬūũŴũ ũūūťŢůŦŧŹũ šŦŞůř-
ŪŢŴũ Ůůū ŢšŜū ůūŰ ŦšŦŴůŦŧūŸ šŦŧŞŜūŰ ũŞ Ť šŜšūŰũ ŨŸŮŢŦŭ ŮůŞ šŸŮŧūŨŞ
ţŤůśŞůŞ, šŦŞůŰŹũūũůŞŭ ŢŰŬŢŜŢŭ ŧŞŦ ŠŢũŦŧŚŭ ŞŬŲŚŭ.
3.
¨ŦŞŦŮůŹũŢůŞŦ ŢŬŞŦůŚŬŴ, ŷůŦ Ť ŚŨŨŢŦųŤ ũūūťŢůŦŧśŭ ŬŷşŨŢųŤŭ ŧŞŦ
ŬŸťŦŮŤŭ Şŷ ůū ŞŠŠŨŦŧŷ šŜŧŞŦū ůūŰ ŞšŦŧŞŦūŨŷŠŤůūŰ ŨūŰůŦŮūŸ šŤŦ-
ūŰŬŠŢŜ ŬūşŨśŞůŞ, ŧŞťŹŭ ŞũŞŧŸůŢŦ Ť ŞũřŠŧŤ ŢŦšŦŧśŭ ũūŦŧśŭ ťŢŢŨŜ-
ŴŮŤŭ ůŤŭ ŞŪŜŴŮŤŭ
187
. ŎŦ ťŢŴŬŤůŦŧūŜ ůūŰ šŦŧŞŜūŰ
188
ŮůŤũ ŬūŮřťŢŦř ůūŰŭ
184.
J. Dawson
, Unjust Enrichment, 1951, 39-40.
185.
J. Stone
, Precedent and Law, 1985, 31,
P. Atiyah
, Common Law and Statute Law,
1985, 48 MLR, 1.
186. “If you think in months, want an instant solution for your problems and do not
mind that it will not wear well, then go for legislation. if you think in decades,
prefer orderly, growth and believe in the old proverb “more haste less speed”,
then stick to the common law”, 1972, J.S.P.T.L. 22, 28.
187.
Ŋ. ŕŬűŭŨŧźŰť
, ņ condictio indebiti, 5,
M. ŒŰşŦŸŬűũŬű
, ńŦšŦŧŷ ńũūŲŦŦŧŷ ¨ŜŧŞŦū,
17 Ţ.
188.
K. Barker
, Unjust Enrichment: Containing the Beast, 1995, 15 OJLS, 457-475,
ŰŬű
ŧŢŝŬű
, Understanding the Unjust Enrhichment Principle in Private Law: a study
of the concept and its reasons ŮŢ: J. Neyers-M. McInnes-S. Pitel, Oxford Hart
Publishing, 2004, 79-110,
ŰŬű ŧŢŝŬű
, Theorising Unjust Enrichment Law-Being
realist(ic)?, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Vol. 26, No. 3, 2006, 609-626,
A.
Botterel
, Property, Corrective Justice, and the Nature of the Cause of Action in
Unjust Enrichment, 2007, 20 Can J L& Juris 275-295,
A. Drassinower
, Unrequested
BeneÀts in the Law of Unjust Enrichment, 1998, 48 U Toronto LJ, 459-488,
T.
Hang Wu,
Natural obligations and the common law of Unjust Enrichment, Oxford
University Commonwealth Law Journal, 2006, 133-156,
D. Klimchuk
, Unjust
Enrichment and Corrective Justice: J. Neyers, M. McInnes and St. Pitel (n 4) 111-
137, The Structure and Content of the Right to Restitution for Unjust Enrichment,
2007, 57 U Toronto L J 661-684,
A. Kull
, Restitution’s Outlaws, Chicago-Kent
Law Review, Vol. 78, 2003, 17-32,
J. Nadler,
What right does Unjust Enrichment
Law protect?, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Vol. 28, No.2, 2008, 245-275,
C.
Rotherham
, Unjust Enrichment and the Autonomy of Law: Private Law as Public