ŎŐňŎŇńŒņőņ Łōňőņő Ł¨ňʼnŁňŎŊŎŃņŒŎœ ŏŊŎœŒňőŋŎœ őŒŎ ńŊŊņŌňʼnŎ & őŒŎ ŁŃŃŊňʼnŎ ¨ňʼnŁňŎ
51
ŮŤŭ ŬŚŢŦ ũŞ šŦŞšŬŞŞůŜŮŢŦ ŚũŞ ŬŷŨū ŮůŤ šŦŚũŢŪŤ ŢůŞŪŸ ůŴũ ŢŬŹũ»
249
.
ʼnŬŜŮŦū ŢŜũŞŦ šŤŨŞšś, ŧŞůř ŷŮūũ ū ŨūŰůŦŮŷŭ ŢůŞűŚŬŢůŞŦ ŮŢ ŞŧūŨūŰ-
ťŜŞ ś Ůůū ŨŞŜŮŦū ŦŞŭ ŮŸşŞŮŤŭ: «ńŜũŞŦ şŞŮŦŧŷ šŷŠŞ ůūŰ šŦŧŞŜūŰ ůŤŭ
ŞūŧŞůřŮůŞŮŤŭ ŷůŦ šŢũ ūŬŢŜ ũŞ ŞūšūťŢŜ ŞūŧŞůřŮůŞŮŤ ŠŦŞ ŢŧŨśŬŴ-
ŮŤ ŦŞŭ ŚŠŧŰŬŤŭ ŰūŲŬŚŴŮŤŭ ūŰ ūűŢŜŨŢůŞŦ Ůůū ŨśůŤ. ņ ŬŷůŞŮŤ űŞŜ-
ũŢůŞŦ ŞŰůŞŷšŢŦŧůŤ»
250
. «ĽūŰ ŚũŞ ŧŚŬšūŭ ŚŲŢŦ ŞūũŢŤťŢŜ şřŮŢŦ ŦŞŭ
šŢŮŢŰůŦŧśŭ ŮŸşŞŮŤŭ, Şŷ ůŤũ ūūŜŞ šŢũ ūŬūŸũ ũŞ ŰŞũŞŲŴŬśŮūŰũ
ůŞ ŚŨŤ, ū ŢũřŠŴũ ŬŚŢŦ ũŞ ŞũŞţŤůśŮŢŦ ůū ŚũšŦŧū şūśťŤŞ şřŮŢŦ ůŤŭ
ŮŸşŞŮŤŭ ŧŞŦ ŷŲŦ şřŮŢŦ ůŤŭ ŞūŧŞůřŮůŞŮŤŭ»
251
. ņ ūŦŧŦŨŜŞ ŮŢ ŞŰůŚŭ ůŦŭ
šŦŞůŰŹŮŢŦŭ šŤŦūŰŬŠŢŜ ŞűŦşūŨŜŞ ŠŦŞ ůū ŧŞůř ŷŮūũ ŧřūŦūŭ Şŷ ŞŰ-
ůūŸŭ ůūŰŭ ŦŮŲŰŬŦŮūŸŭ ŢŜũŞŦ ŢŰŬŸůŢŬŞ ŞūšŢŧůŷŭ
252
.
Ŏ ŢũřŠŴũ ūŬŢŜ ũŞ ŰūŮůŤŬŜŪŢŦ ŷůŦ Ť ŮŸşŞŮŤ ŚŲŢŦ řųŢŦ ũŞ ŢŜũŞŦ ŮŢ
ŦŮŲŸ, ŷůŞũ ŞŰůś šŢũ ŧŞůŞŬůŜŮůŤŧŢ ūůŚ ś śůŞũ ŠŦŞ ŧřūŦū ũūŦŧŷ ŨŷŠū
ŢŪŞŬŲśŭ řŧŰŬŤ, ŞŬŞşŦřŮůŤŧŢ Şŷ ůū ŚũŞ ŚŬūŭ ŧŞŦ ůū řŨŨū ŚŬūŭ ŰŞ-
ũŞŲŹŬŤŮŢ, ŞŧŰŬŹťŤŧŢ
253
ś ŷůŦ ū ŢũŞŠŷŢũūŭ šŢũ ŢŜũŞŦ ŚůūŦūŭ, ŦŧŞũŷŭ ś
ŬŷťŰūŭ ŠŦŞ ůŤũ ŢŧŨśŬŴŮś ůŤŭ
254
.
ĺŲŢŦ ŷŴŭ šŦŞůŰŴťŢŜ ŧŞŦ Ť Ŧū ŮůŢũś ŚũũūŦŞ ŢŦŧūŰŬŦŧŷůŤůŞŭ, ŮŸűŴũŞ
Ţ ůŤũ ūūŜŞ, ŞŞŦůŢŜůŞŦ Şŷ ůū šŦŧŞŮůśŬŦū ũŞ ŬūŮšŦūŬŜŮŢŦ ŧŞůř ŷŮūũ
Ť ŮŰŠŧŢŧŬŦŚũŤ ŢůŞűūŬř ŞűūŬūŸŮŢ ŧŞůŞũŢŤŚũū Şŷ ůŤ ŮŸşŞŮŤ ŧŜũ-
šŰũū
255
, ŧŞůř ŷŮūũ ŧŞŨŸůŢůŞŦ šŤŨŞšś Şŷ ůū ŢŬŦŢŲŷŢũū ůŤŭ ŮŸşŞ-
249.
G. Virgo
, The Principles of the Law of Restitution, 2nd edition, Oxford University
Press, Oxford 2006, 40.
250.
D. Friedmann
, Valid, voidable, qualiÀed, and non existing obligations: an
alternative perspective on the law of restitution, ŮŢ: Burrows (ed.), Essays on
the Law of Restitution (n.4), 247-8.
251.
R. Goff and G. Jones
: the Law of Restitution (Sweet and Maxwell, London 1966)
21.
252.
G. Virgo,
Failure of Consideration: myth and meaning in the English Law of
Restitution ŮŢ: Johnston-Zimmermann (eds), UnjustiÀed Enrichment: Key Issues
in Comparative Perspective, 2002, 109,
St. Waddams
, The relation between
Contract and Unjust Enrichment ŮŢ P. Giliker, Re-examining Contract and Unjust
Enrichment: anglo-canadian perspectives, Martimus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden-
Boston, 2007, 17.
253. Fibrosa Spolka Akcujna v. Fairbairn Lawson Combe Barbour Ltd 1943, AC 32.
254. Thomas v. Brown (1876) 1 QB 714.
255.
J. Beatson
, The temptation of elegance: concurrence of restitutionary and
contractual claims ŮŢ: W. Swadling - G. Jones (eds), The search for principle: Essays
in Honour of Lord Goff of Chieveley, Oxford University Press, 1999, 153-154,,
ŰŬű
ŧŢŝŬű
, Resitution and Contract: Non-Cumul?, 2000, 1 Theoritical Inquiries in Law,
94-96,
P. Birks,
Failure of Consideration nad its place on the map, 2002, 2 Oxford