ņ Łōňőņ Ł¨ňʼnŁňŎŊŎŃņŒŎœ ŏŊŎœŒňőŋŎœ őŒŎ ńŊŊņŌňʼnŎ ʼnŁň őŒŎ ŁŃŃŊňʼnŎ ¨ňʼnŁňŎ
52
ŮŤŭ. őŸűŴũŞ Ţ ůŤũ řūųŤ ŞŰůśũ, ŢŧŢŜ ŷūŰ ůŞ ŚŬŤ ŚŲūŰũ ŰūŠŬřųŢŦ
ŦŞ ŮŸşŞŮŤ ūŰ ŧŞůŞũŚŢŦ ůūŰŭ ŧŦũšŸũūŰŭ ŢůŞŪŸ ůūŰŭ Şŷ šŦřűūŬŞ
ŠŢŠūũŷůŞ, ŢŜũŞŦ šŜŧŞŦū ŠŦ’ ŞŰůūŸŭ ũŞ ŢűŞŬūŮůŢŜ Ť ŮŰşŞůŦŧś ŧŞůŞũūś,
ŢũŹ ťŞ śůŞũ ŮűřŨŞ ũŞ ŢŞũŞŧŞůŞũŢŤťūŸũ ūŦ ŧŜũšŰũūŦ ŢŜ ůŤ şřŮŢŦ
ůūŰ šŦŧŞŜūŰ ůūŰ ŞšŦŧŞŦūŨŷŠŤůūŰ ŨūŰůŦŮūŸ
256
. ŃŦŞ ůū ŨŷŠū ŞŰůŷ, ŢŜũŞŦ
ŢŷŢũū ũŞ ťŢŴŬŢŜůŞŦ ůū ŚũšŦŧū şūśťŤŞ Şŷ ŞšŦŧŞŦūŨŷŠŤůū ŨūŰůŦŮŷ
Űŷ ŞŰůś ůŤũ ŚũũūŦŞ Ŵŭ ŢŦşūŤťŤůŦŧŷ
257
. ņ ŮŸşŞŮŤ ŢŦůŬŚŢŦ ŮůŞ ŚŬŤ
ũŞ ŬūŮšŦūŬŜţūŰũ ŬūŧŞůŞşūŨŦŧř ůūũ ŧŜũšŰũū ŢůŞŪŸ ůūŰŭ. Ŏ ŞšŦŧŞŦū-
ŨŷŠŤůūŭ ŨūŰůŦŮŷŭ, ŞũůŜťŢůŞ, ŧŞůŞũŚŢŦ ůūŰŭ ŧŦũšŸũūŰŭ ex post ŠŦŞ ũŞ
šŦūŬťŹŮŢŦ ůŤũ «ŞũŦŮūŬŬūŜŞ» ūŰ ŬūŚŧŰųŢ ŢŪŞŦůŜŞŭ ůŤŭ ŢůŞűūŬřŭ.
ńřũ ŞŰůŚŭ ūŦ šŸū ŬūŮŢŠŠŜŮŢŦŭ ŮŰŠŧŬūŰŮůūŸũ, ťŞ ŰŢŬŦŮŲŸŮŢŦ Ť ŮŸşŞ-
ŮŤ ŞũůŜ ůūŰ ŞšŦŧŞŦūŨŷŠŤůūŰ ŨūŰůŦŮūŸ
258
. Ŏ ŮŢşŞŮŷŭ ŠŦŞ ůŤũ ŦšŦŴůŦŧś
ŞŰůūũūŜŞ ŬūŴťŢŜ ůŤũ ŮŰşŞůŦŧś ŧŞůŞũūś ůūŰ ŧŦũšŸũūŰ ŞŬř ůŤũ ŧŞ-
ůŞũūś ůŴũ şŞŬŹũ ūŰ ŢŦůŰŠŲřũŢůŞŦ ŚŮŴ ůŤŭ ŞŰůŷŞůŤŭ ŬŰťŦŮůŦŧśŭ
ŨŢŦůūŰŬŠŜŞŭ ůūŰ šŦŧŞŜūŰ.
Ŏ ŧŞťŤŠŤůśŭ Burrows šŦŧŞŦūŨūŠŢŜ ůŤũ řūųŤ ŞŰůś Ţ ůŤ ŮŧŚųŤ ŷůŦ šŢũ
ŬŚŢŦ ũŞ šŢŮŢŸŢůŞŦ ŮŰşŞůŦŧř ŚũŞ ŚŬūŭ ũŞ ŢŦŮůŬŚųŢŦ ŚũŞ ŧŚŬšūŭ,
ůū ūūŜū ůū šŜŧŞŦū ůūŰ ŞšŦŧŞŦūŨŷŠŤůūŰ ŨūŰůŦŮūŸ ŞŞŦůŢŜ ũŞ ŢŦŮůŬŞ-
űŢŜ
259
.
University Commonwealth Law Journal 1, 5,
R. Cunningham
, Failyre of Basis,
2004, Lloyd’s Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly 234, 250,
P. Maddaugh and
J. McCamus
, The Law of Restitution, Canada Law Book, 2nd ed., 2004, 3.200.30,
M. McInnes
, Unjust factors, juristic reasons and contracts in Anglo-Canadian Law
ŮŢ: P.Giliker, Re-examininng contract and unjust enrichment, anglo-canadian
perspectives, Martimus Nijheff Publishers, Laiden/Boston, 2007, 31,
G. Mead
,
Restitution with Contract?, 1991, 11 Legal Studies, 172,
A. Tettenborn
, Subsisting
Contract and Failure of Consideration - A little scepticism, 2002, Restitution Law
Review, 1-2.
256.
D. Johnston - R. Zimmermann
, UnjustiÀed Enrichment: Surveying the landscape
ŮŢ: Unjust Enrichment: Key Issues in Comparative Perspective, Cambridge
University Press, 2002, 10.
257.
L. Smith,
Property, Subsidiarity and Unjust Enrichment ŮŢ: D. Johnston - R.
Zimmermann, Unjust Enrichment, Key Issues in Comparative Perspective,
Campridge University Press, 2006, 509 Ţ.
258.
M. McInnes
, Unjust factors, juristic reasons and contracts in Anglo-Canadian Law
ŮŢ: P. Giliker, Re-examininng contract and unjust enrichment, anglo-canadian
perspectives, Martimus Nijhoff Publishers, Laiden/Boston, 2007, 29.
259.
A. Burrows,
Restitution from Assignees (The Trident Beauty), 1994, ŮŢŨ.
54,
ŰŬű ŧŢŝŬű
, The Law of Restitution, Butterworths, 2nd ed., 2002, 323-324,
D. Friedmann
, Valid, Voidable, QualiÀed, and Non-Exissting Obligations: an
alternative perspective on the Law of Restitution, Oxford University Press, 1991,