±¯ ¦§¡¦¯ ¯² ¦££¦ ±¥® ¡§¥¥ ±¥ ¦§¡¦¯¯±¦§¥ £¦±¯²°¦¡
103
ÅÐÁÉÒ»ÐÔ. ÒÈ ÑÀÇÖÐÎÍÈ ÄÉÁÉÒÈѽÁ, »ÖÎ×Í ÄÉÁÎÐÆÔÓŽ ÑÀÍÎÌÁ ËÁ;ÍÔÍ ÄÉÁÄÉËÁ-
ѽÁÕ, ÒÈÍ ÅÆÁÐÎǼ ÒÔÍ ÎνÔÍ ÎÐÎÀÍ ÍÁ ÅÉÌ»ÊÎ×Í ÒÁ »ÐÈ, ÅÍÏ ÑÅ ÎÐÉÑ»ÍÅÕ
ÅÐÉÒÏÑÅÉÕ È ÅÆÁÐÎǼ ÅÍ¾Õ Ñ×ÇËÅËÐÉ»ÍÎ× ÄÉÁÄÉËÁÑÒÉËÎÀ ÌÁÉѽÎ× ËÁÓ½ÑÒÁÒÁÉ
×ÎÖÐÅÔÒÉ˼, ÉĽÔÕ ÑÒÈ ÓÅÑÉ˼ ÄÉÁÉÒÈѽÁ.
ÒÈÍ ÐÏÒÈ ËÁÒÅÀÓ×ÍÑÈ, ÑÒÎ×Õ Ë¾ÌÎ×Õ ÒÎ× ÉÁÐËÎÀÕ ÉËÁÑÒÈнÎ× ÉÁÉÒÈѽÁÕ,
»ÖÎ×Í ×ÉÎÓÅÒÈÓŽ ÐÎÁÉÐÅÒÉËν ËÁ;ÍÅÕ Î× Ñ×ÌÈÐÏÍÎ×Í ÒÉÕ Ð×Ó½ÑÅÉÕ ÒÔÍ
×ÂÑÅÔÍ ÒÈÕ ³ÇÈÕ, ÐÎÑÁоØÎÍÒÁÕ ÒÈ ÄÉÁÉÒÈÒÉ˼ ÄÉÁÄÉËÁѽÁ ÑÒÁ ÉÄÉÁ½ÒÅÐÁ ÖÁ-
ÐÁËÒÈÐÉÑÒÉË ÒÔÍ ÄÉÁƾÐÔÍ ÒÀÔÍ ÄÉÅÓÍÏÍ ÄÉÁÆÎÐÏÍ
22
.
»ÐÁÍ Á×ÒÏÍ, ÑÒÈ ÓÅÑÉ˼ ÄÉÁÉÒÈѽÁ, ÒÎ ÄÉÁÄÉËÁÑÒÉ˾ ÌÁ½ÑÉΠŽÍÁÉ ÐÎËÁÓÎÐÉ-
Ñ»ÍÎ, ÅÐÉÎнØÎÍÒÁÕ ÔÕ »ÍÁ ÂÁÓ¾ ÒÈÍ ÄÉÁËÐÉÒÉ˼ Å×Ö»ÐÅÉÁ ÒÔÍ ÅÐÏÍ. ±ÎÀÒÎ ÉÑÖÀ-
ÅÉ ÇÉÁ ÁÐÄÅÉÇÁ ÔÕ ÐÎÕ ÒÁ ÄÉÁÉÒÈÒÉË ÄÉËÁÑÒ¼ÐÉÁ Î× Ñ×ÇËÐÎÒÎÀÍÒÁÉ ÑÒÎ ÌÁ½-
ÑÉÎ ÒÎ× ÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ §»ÍÒÐÎ× £½Ì×ÑÈÕ ÉÁÆÎÐÏÍ £ÅÍÄÀÑÅÔÍ (ICSID) Î× ×ÇÎÍÒÁÉ
ÑÒÎ×Õ ÄÉÁÄÉËÁÑÒÉËÎÀÕ ËÁ;ÍÅÕ Î× ÅÅÐÉ»ÖÎÍÒÁÉ ÑÒÈ ÀÂÁÑÈ ÒÎ× 1965, ÅËÒ¾Õ ÁÍ
ÒÁ »ÐÈ Ñ×ÆÔͼÑÎ×Í ÁÌÌÉÏÕ
23
.
¨»ÑÁ Á¾ Á×Ò»Õ ÒÉÕ ÄÉÆÎÐÅÕ Ð×Ó½ÑÅÉÕ, È ÄÉÁÉÒÈÒÉ˼ ÄÉÁÄÉËÁѽÁ »ÖÅÉ ÑÅ ÅÇÌÎ
ÂÁÓ¾ ÎÎÇÅÍÎÎÉÈÓŽ
24
. ±Á×Ò¾ÖÐÎÍÁ, Ñ×ÍÅÖ½ØÅÉ ÍÁ Ñ×ÍÉÑÒ ËÀÐÉÎ ÑÒÎÉÖÅ½Î È ÅÇÁ-
ÌÀÒÅÐÈ Å×Ö»ÐÅÉÁ ÒÔÍ ÅÐÏÍ ÔÕ ÐÎÕ ÒÈÍ ÅÉÌÎǼ ÒÎ× ÄÉÁÄÉËÁÑÒÉËÎÀ ÑÖ¼ÁÒÎÕ Î×
ÓÁ ÁËÎÌÎ×ÓÈÓŽ. ¥ Å×ÅÌÉʽÁ ÒÈÕ ÄÉÁÉÒÈѽÁÕ Å½ÍÁÉ ÌÌÔÑÒÅ »ÍÁ ÖÁÐÁËÒÈÐÉÑÒÉ˾ Î×
ÆÁ½ÍÅÒÁÉ ÍÁ ÅÉÓ×ÎÀÍ ÍÁ ÄÉÁÒÈмÑÎ×Í ÒÁ ËÐÒÈ. ¡×Ò¾ ËÁÒ»ÑÒÈ ÅÆÁÍ»Õ ËÁÉ Á¾ ÒÉÕ
ÁÍÒÉÄÐÑÅÉÕ ÒÔÍ ËÐÁÒÏÍ ÑÅ ÅÒÁÇÅÍ»ÑÒÅÐÅÕ ÐÎÑÓÅÉÅÕ ËÔÄÉËÎνÈÑÈÕ ÒÎ× ÄÉËÁ½-
Î× ÒÈÕ ÄÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ ÄÉÁÉÒÈѽÁÕ. ÐÇÁÒÉ, È £ÉÒÐμ ÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ ÉËÁ½Î× ÒÔÍ ¥ÍÔ»ÍÔÍ
£ÓÍÏÍ ÁÑÖÎ̼ÓÈËÅ Á¾ ÒÎ 1950 Å ÒÈ ËÔÄÉËÎνÈÑÈ ÒÎ× ÄÉËÁ½Î× ÒÈÕ ÄÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ ÄÉ-
ÁÉÒÈѽÁÕ Å ÑËξ ÒÈÍ Å˾ÍÈÑÈ ÅÍ¾Õ ËÏÄÉËÁ ÄÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ ÄÉÁÉÒÈѽÁÕ
25
. ±Î ÑÖ»ÄÉÎ Ð-
ÓÐÔÍ Î× ÒÅÌÉËÐÎÒÓÈËÅ Á¾ ÒÈÍ £ÉÒÐμ ËÁÉ ÒÎÍ £ÉÄÉ˾ £ÉÑÈÇÈÒ¼, G. Scelle, Î
ÎνÎÕ ×¼ÐÊÅ Î ËÀÐÉÎÕ ÅÍÅ×ÑÒ¼Õ ÒÈÕ ÐÎÑÓÅÉÁÕ, ÄÅÍ »ÇÉÍÅ ÒÅÌÉËÁÎÄÅËÒ¾ Á¾
ÒÁ ËÐÒÈ ÔÕ ÄÉÅÓÍ¼Õ ÑÀÂÁÑÈ, ÁÌÌ×ÉÎÓÅÒ¼ÓÈËÅ ÔÕ «×¾ÄÅÉÇÁ ËÁ;ÍÔÍ ÒÈÕ ÄÉÁÉ-
ÒÈÒÉË¼Õ ÄÉÁÄÉËÁѽÁÕ»
26
. ¥ ÂÁÑÉ˼ ÁÍÒ½ÐÐÈÑÈ Î× ÐÎÂ̼ÓÈËÅ ¼ÒÁÍ ¾ÒÉ ÎÉ Ð×Ó½ÑÅÉÕ
»ÂÁÉÍÁÍ »ÐÁÍ ÒÈÕ ËÔÄÉËÎνÈÑÈÕ ÒÎ× ×ÆÉÑÒÅÍÎ× ÄÉËÁ½Î×, ÐÎÕ ÒÈÍ ËÁÒÅÀÓ×ÍÑÈ
22.
Optional Rules for Arbitrating Disputes between Two States
(1992),
Optional Rules for
Arbitrating Disputes between Two Parties of which Only One is a State
(1993)
, Optional
Rules for Arbitration Involving International Organizations and States
(1996),
Optional
Rules for Arbitration between International Organizations and Private Parties
(1996),
Optional Rules for Arbitration of Disputes Relating to Natural Resources and/or the
Environment
(2001), ÇÉÁ ÉÁ ÅÉÑ˾ÈÑÈ, ÂÌ. B. Daly, “The Permanent Court of Arbitration”,
C. Giorgetti (ed.),
The Rules, Practice and Jurisprudence of International Courts and
Tribunals
, ¾. ÁÐ., ÑÅÌ. 37-73.
23. ´ÐÓÐÎ 44 ÀÂÁÑÈÕ ICSID.
24. J. Collier & V. Lowe,
The Settlement of Disputes in International Law
, ¾. ÁÐ., ÑÅÌ. 189Å., B.
Daly, “The Permanent Court of Arbitration”, ¾. ÁÐ., ÉĽÔÕ ÑÅÌ. 42-49.
25. ¢Ì. ÒÉÕ ÄÉÁÄÎÖÉË»Õ £ËÓ»ÑÅÉÕ ÒÈÕ £ÉÒÐμÕ:
Yearbook of the International Law Commission
,
1950 (UN Doc. A/CN.4/18), 1952 (UN Doc. A/CN.4/59), 1953 (UN Doc A/CN.4/76), 1958 (UN
Doc. A/CN.4/113).
26.
Yearbook of the International Law Commission
, 1958, UN Doc. A/3859.