ΕΜΜΕΣΗ ΚΑΤΟΧΗ ΚΙΝΗΤΩΝ ΑΞΙΩΝ ΣΤΟ ΙΔΙΩΤΙΚΟ ΔΙΕΘΝΕΣ ΔΙΚΑΙΟ

26 / 44

56 ±¯ ž°¯¢œ¥¨¡ ±¥Ÿ £¨¨£Ÿ¥Ÿ §¡±¯³¥Ÿ ±¦±œ¬® Ÿ±¯ ¦š¦¬±¦§¯ š¦£›®£Ÿ š¦§¡¦¯
ÒÔÍ Ñ×ÍÁÌÌÁÇÏÍ, ÁÎÒÅÌÎÀÍ ÑÒÎÉÖŽÁ Î× ÅÍÄ»ÖÅÒÁÉ ÍÁ Ñ×ÍÄ»Î×Í ŒÉÁ ÑÖ»ÑÈ »ŒŒÅÑÈÕ ËÁÒÎÖ¼Õ
Ò½ÒÌÔÍ ŒÅ ÅÐÉÑѾÒÅÐÅÕ ÒÈÕ ŒÉÁÕ »ÍÍΌÅÕ ÒÊÅÉÕ. µÒÑÉ, È ËÁÒÎÖ¼ ËÁÉ ÄÉÅÍ»ÐÇÅÉÁ Ñ×ÍÁÌÌÁÇÏÍ Å½
ŌŒ»ÑÔÕ ËÁÒÅÖ¾ŒÅÍÔÍ Ò½ÒÌÔÍ ÑÅ ÄÉÁÑ×ÍÎÐÉÁ˾ ō½ÅÄÎ ÐÎÑĽÄÅÉ ÑÒÉÕ ÄȌÉÎ×ÐÇÎÀŒÅÍÅÕ ÑÖ»-
ÑÅÉÕ ÑÒÎÉÖŽÁ ÁÌÌÎÄÁ¾ÒÈÒÁÕ, ÅÇŽÐÎÍÒÁÕ ØÈÒ¼ŒÁÒÁ ÉÄÉÔÒÉËÎÀ ÄÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ ÄÉËÁ½Î×.
£ÀÌÎÇÁ ÄÅ, ÒÎ ÐÏÒÎ ÅÐÏÒȌÁ ÁÍÁÆÎÐÉˌŠÒÈÍ ËÁÒÌÌÈÌÈ ÉÄÉÔÒÉËÎÄÉÅÓÍÎÌÎÇÉ˼ ÐÎÑ»ÇÇÉ-
ÑÈ ÒÈÕ ÑÀÇÖÐÎÍÈÕ »ŒŒÅÑÈÕ ËÁÒÎÖ¼Õ Ò½ÒÌÔÍ Å½ÍÁÉ ÁÍ ÎÉ ¼ÄÈ ×ÆÉÑҌÅÍÎÉ ËÁ;ÍÅÕ ÒÎ× ÉÄÉÔÒÉËÎÀ
ÄÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ ÄÉËÁ½Î× ÄÀÍÁÍÒÁÉ ÍÁ ÅÆÁЌÎÑÒÎÀÍ ÅÉÒ×ÖÏÕ ËÁÉ ÑÒÎ ÌÁ½ÑÉÎ ÒÔÍ Í»ÔÍ ÄΌÏÍ ÒÔÍ
Ñ×ÍÁÌÌÁÇÏÍ. Ÿ×ÇËÅËÐɌ»ÍÁ, È ŒÅÒÁÒ¾ÉÑÈ ÒÈÕ ÂÁÐÀÒÈÒÁÕ Á¾ ÒÈÍ ËÁÒÎÖ¼ ÒÎ× ÖÁÐÒ½Î× ¼ ÒÈÍ
ËÁÒÁÖÏÐÈÑÈ ÑÒÎ ŒÈÒÐÏÎ ÄÉËÁÉÎÀÖÔÍ ÒÎ× ÅËľÒÈ, ÑÒÈ ÑÖ»ÑÈ ŒÅÒÁÊÀ ÅÍÄɌÅÑÎ× ËÁÉ ÅÅÍÄ×-
Ò¼, È ÎÎ½Á ŽÍÁÉ ËÁÉ È ËнÑÉŒÈ ÑÒÈÍ »ŒŒÅÑÈ ËÁÒÎÖ¼ Ò½ÒÌÔÍ, ËÁÉ È ÅÍ Ç»ÍÅÉ ÄÉÁÆÎÐ΍ÎÉȌ»ÍÈ
ÄΌ¼ ÒÈÕ ÒÅÌÅ×ÒÁ½ÁÕ Á¾ ÒÈÍ ÁÐÁÄÎÑÉÁ˼ ÑÖ»ÑÈ ÒÎ× ÅÅÍÄ×Ò¼ ŒÅ ÒÎ×Õ Ò½ÒÌÎ×Õ, ¼ÇÅÉÐÁÍ ÅÐÔ-
Ò¼ŒÁÒÁ ÇÉÁ ÒÈÍ ÁÍÇËÈ ÅÍ Ç»ÍÅÉ ÅËÑ×ÇÖÐÎÍÉьÎÀ ÒÎ× ÌÁÉѽÎ× ÒÔÍ Ñ×ÍÁÌÌÁÇÏÍ Å½ Ò½ÒÌÔÍ ÑÅ
ÄÉÅÓÍ»Õ Å½ÅÄÎ ÁÌÌËÁÉ ÅÉÄÉ˾ÒÅÐÁ ÇÉÁ ÒÈÍ ÐÎÑÆÎоÒÈÒÁ ÒÔÍ ÁÐÁÄÎÑÉÁËÏÍ ËÁ;ÍÔÍ ÑÀ-
ÇËÐÎ×ÑÈÕ, ËÁÉ ÉĽÔÕ ÒÈÕ Ë×нÁÐÖÈÕ ÑÒÈÍ ŒÅÑÈ ËÁÒÎÖ¼ ÁÊÉÎÇÐÆÔÍ lex cartae sitae, ÁÍÁÆÎ-
ÐÉË ŒÅ ÒÈÍ ËÁÒÁÌÌÈ̾ÒÈÒ ÒÎ×Õ ÍÁ ÅÆÁЌÎÑÒÎÀÍ ÅÉÒ×ÖÏÕ ËÁÉ ÍÁ ÎÄÈǼÑÎ×Í ÑÅ ÁÎÄÅËÒ»Õ
ÌÀÑÅÉÕ ÑÒÎ ÌÁ½ÑÉÎ ÒÔÍ Í»ÔÍ Ñ×ÑÒȌÒÔÍ ËÁÒÎÖ¼Õ254.
¦ÄÉÁ½ÒÅÐÈ ÑȌÁѽÁ ËÁÉ »ŒÆÁÑÈ, ÁÎĽÄÅÒÁÉ ÎŒ¾ÆÔÍÁ ÑÒÈÍ ÁÍÇËÈ ÀÁÐÊÈÕ Å×ÐÀÒÅÐÁ ÁÎ-
ÄÅËÒÏÍ ËÁ;ÍÔÍ ÉÄÉÔÒÉËÎÀ ÄÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ ÄÉËÁ½Î×, ÎÉ ÎÎ½ÎÉ ÍÁ ÎнØÎ×Í ŒÅ ÒоÎ ÑÁƼ, ÐÎÂÌ»-
ÃɌΠËÁÉ ÁÑÆÁ̼ ÒΠĽËÁÉÎ Î× Ò×ÇÖÍÅÉ ÅÆÁЌÎÑһΠÑÒÉÕ ÅÍ Ì¾ÇÔ »ÍÍΌÅÕ ÑÖ»ÑÅÉÕ255. ¥ ÁÄ×-
ÍÁŒ½Á ÒÎ× ÄÉËÁ½Î×, ŽÒÅ ÒÎ× Î×ÑÉÁÑÒÉËÎÀ, ŽÒÅ ÒÎ× ÉÄÉÔÒÉËÎÀ ÄÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ, ÍÁ ÄÉÁÑÆÁ̽ØÅÉ ÌÀÑÅÉÕ
ÐÎÂÌ»ÃɌÅÕ ËÁÉ ÐÁËÒÉË ÅÆÁЌ¾ÑɌÅÕ, ÎÉ ÎÎ½ÅÕ ÍÁ ÅÊ׍ÈÐÅÒÎÀÍ ÒÉÕ ÅÀÌÎÇÅÕ ÐÎÑÄÎ˽ÅÕ
ÒÔÍ Ñ×ÍÁÌÌÁÑѾŒÅÍÔÍ ËÁÉ ÍÁ ÉËÁÍ΍ÎÉÎÀÍ ÒÉÕ ÁÍÇËÅÕ ÒÔÍ Ñ×ÍÁÌÌÁÇÏÍ, »ÖÅÉ ÅÀÑÒÎÖÁ ōÉÑÈ-
ŒÁÍÓŽ ÔÕ ŒÎÐƼ ÍΌÉËÎÀ ËÉÍÄÀÍÎ×256. ¨ÌÉÑÒÁ, ÁÐÁÒÈÐŽÒÁÉ ¾ÒÉ ÉÄÉÁ½ÒÅÐÁ ÑÒΠ׍¾ ÅÊ»ÒÁÑÈ
254. ¢Ì. ¢Ð»ÌÌÈ Ÿ., ±Î ÅÆÁЌÎÑһΠĽËÁÉÎ ÑÅ ËÉÍÈÒ»Õ ÁʽÅÕ Î× ËÁÒ»ÖÎÍÒÁÉ Á¾ ÅÍÄɌÅÑÁ Ð¾ÑԍÁ,
š.£.£. 2006, 229, ÑÅÌ. 231.
255. ¢Ì. "HC Expl. Rep.", ÁÐ. Int. 2 ō. ËÁÉ ×ÎÑ. 3, Gyunn R., Modernizing Securities Ownership,
Transfer and Pledging Laws, ÑÅÌ. 10., £×ÐԍÁÙ˼ §ÅÍÒÐÉ˼ ±ÐÅØÁ, ™ÍÏŒÈ ÒÈÕ £×ÐԍÁÙË¼Õ §ÅÍÒÐÉ-
Ë¼Õ ±ÐÅØÁÕ ÒÈÕ 17ÈÕ ¨ÁÐÒ½Î× 2005 ËÁÒ¾ÉÍ ÁÉÒ¼ŒÁÒÎÕ ÒÎ× Ÿ×ŒÂÎ×̽Î× ÒÈÕ £×ÐԍÁÙË¼Õ µÍÔÑÈÕ
ÁÍÁÆÎÐÉË ŒÅ Ð¾ÒÁÑÈ Á¾ÆÁÑÈÕ ÒÎ× Ÿ×ŒÂÎ×̽Î× ÑÖÅÒÉË ŒÅ ÒÈÍ ×ÎÇÐÁƼ ÒÈÕ ŸÀŒÂÁÑÈÕ ÒÈÕ
³ÇÈÕ ÇÉÁ ÒÎ ÅÆÁЌÎÑһΠĽËÁÉÎ ÑÅ ÎÐÉь»ÍÁ ÄÉËÁÉόÁÒÁ ō½ Ò½ÒÌÔÍ Î× ËÁÒ»ÖÎÍÒÁÉ Á¾ ÄÉÁŒÅ-
ÑÎÌÁÂÈÒ»Õ [COM(2003) 783 ÒÅÌÉ˾], CON/2005/7, ££ C 81/10, 2.4.2005, ׍¾ ÑÒÎÉÖ. 5, European
Commission, Commission Staff Working Document, Legal assessment of certain aspects of the
Hague Securities Convention Brussels, 03.07.2006, SEC (2006) 910, ÑÅÌ. 5, Bank for International
Settlements, Cross-border Securities Settlement, ÑÅÌ. 46 ō., £×ÐԍÁÙ˾ §ÎÉÍÎÂÎÀÌÉÎ, «¼ÆÉьÁ
ÒÎ× £×ÐԍÁÙËÎÀ §ÎÉÍÎÂÎ×̽Î× ÑÖÅÒÉË ŒÅ ÒÉÕ Ñ×Í»ÅÉÅÕ ÒÈÕ ×ÎÇÐÁÆ¼Õ ÒÈÕ ŸÀŒÂÁÑÈÕ ÒÈÕ ³ÇÈÕ
ÇÉÁ ÒÎ×Õ Ò½ÒÌÎ×Õ, ÒÈÕ 14.12.2006, P6_TA(2006)0608, ÑȌŽΠ4.
256. Morton G., Legal risk and its impact on market efficiency, UNIDROIT Seminar on Harmonised
Substantive Rules regarding Securities Held with an Intermediary, Rome 12 November 2003,
Report (Febuary 2004), ÑÅÌ. 4, Π΍νÎÕ ÎнØÅÉ ÒÎ ÍΌÉ˾ ˽ÍÄ×ÍÎ ÔÕ "The risk that the law fails to
deliver predictable and practical results". ™ÉÁ ÌÌÎ×Õ ÎÐÉьÎÀÕ ËÁÉ ÁÍÁÆÎÐ ÑÒÉÕ ŒÎÐÆ»Õ ÍΌÉËÎÀ
ËÉÍÄÀÍÎ× ÑÒÉÕ ÖÐȌÁÒ΍ÉÑÒÔÒÉË»Õ ÁÇÎÐ»Õ ÂÌ. McCormick R., Legal Risk in the Financial Markets,
Oxford 2010, passim ËÁÉ ÉĽÔÕ ÑÅÌ. 239 ō. ÁÍÁÆÎÐÉˌŠÒÎ×Õ Ò½ÒÌÎ×Õ Î× ËÁÒ»ÖÎÍÒÁÉ Œ»ÑÔ ÅÍÄÉ-
ŒÅÑÔÍ ÔÕ ÁÐÄÅÉnjÁ ÍΌÉËÎÀ ËÉÍÄÀÍÎ×. ™ÉÁ ËÁÒÈÇÎÐÉ΍νÈÑÈ ÒÔÍ ÈÇÏÍ ÒÎ× ÍΌÉËÎÀ ËÉÍÄÀÍÎ×
ÂÌ. Benjamin J., Sources of legal risk for financial institutions, J.I.B.F.L. Special Supplement, April
2004, 18, ÑÅÌ. 18 ō.
119
120