. ¡¤¡°¦¡
3
¦£®¥¦§±²¡£®£°£¦¡§¡¦°¬±¯£®£¦
²¨¢¡±¦§£²¯³°£¬£¦§°¡±¬®
ÁÍÈ¡ØÁнÁ
*
¦. £¦¡¬¥
ÒÎ ÁÐ¾Í ËÅÆÌÁÉΠǽÍÅÒÁÉ ½Á ÅÉÑ˾ÈÑÈ, ÐÏÒÎÍ ÒÎ× ÅÐÉÅÖλÍÎ× ÎÐÉÑ»ÍÔÍ
Ñ×ÂÁÒÉËÏÍ ×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÔÍ ËÐÁÒÏÍ ÑÅ ÑÖ»ÑÈ Å ÒÈ ÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈ ÅÍ»ÐÇÅÉÁÕ »ÑÔ ÁÇÔÇÏÍ,
ÎÉ ÎνÎÉ ÂнÑËÎÍÒÁÉ ¼Ð¾ËÅÉÒÁÉ ÍÁ ËÁÒÁÑËÅ×ÁÑÓÎÀÍ ÑÒÎ »ÄÁÆ¾Õ ÒÎ×Õ (¼ÑÅ ÓÁÌÑÑÉÅÕ
ØÏÍÅÕ, ¾Î× ÒÁËÐÒÈÁÑËÎÀÍÄÉËÁÉÎÄÎѽÁ), ËÁÉ ÄÅÀÒÅÐÎÍ ÒÈÕÑÖ»ÑÈÕ ÒÔÍ×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÔÍ
×¾ ÄÉÁÆÎÐÅÒÉË»Õ Ñ×ÍÓ¼ËÅÕ ÅÒÁÊÀ ÒÎ×Õ. ¥ ÅÌ»ÒÈ ÁÎËÁÌÀÒÅÉ ÒÈÍ ÀÁÐÊÈ ÎÉËÉ̽ÁÕ
Ñ×ÂÁÒÉËÏÍÐÔÒÎÇÅÍÏÍËÁ;ÍÔÍËÁÉ ÄÉÁÆÎÐÅÒÉË»ÕÑÖ»ÑÅÉÕÅÒÁÊÀ ÒÎ×Õ.
×ͼÓÔÕ, ÎÉ ÄÉÁÑ×ÍÎÐÉÁËν ÁÇÔÇν ÅÒÐÅÌÁ½Î× ËÁÉ Æ×ÑÉËÎÀÁÅнÎ×ÑÒÈнØÎÍÒÁÉ ÑÅ ÉÁ
ÑÅÉÐÑׯÔÍÉÏÍ: ÉÁÑ×ÍÓ¼ËÈÅÒÁÊÀ ÒÔÍ ÖÔÐÏÍ ¾Î×ÂнÑËÅÒÁÉ ÎÁÇÔǾÕ, ÈÎνÁ
Ñ×ÖÍ ÁÎËÁÌŽÒÁÉ ÉÁ ‘ÄÉÁË×ÂÅÐÍÈÒÉ˼ ÑׯÔͽÁ’.
1
ׯÔͽÅÕ ÅÒÁÊÀ ÒÎ× ËÐÒÎ×Õ,
ÑÒÎ ÎνΠÂнÑËÅÒÁÉ ¼ оËÅÉÒÁÉ ÍÁ ËÁÒÁÑËÅ×ÁÑÒŽ Î ÁÇÔǾÕ, ËÁÉ ÒÎ×Õ ÅÅÍÄ×Ò»Õ ÒÎ×
»ÐÇÎ×.
2
§ÁÉ ÅÎÐÉË»Õ ÑׯÔͽÅÕ ÒÎ× »ÐÇÎ×.
3
¥ ÁÐÎÀÑÁ ÅÌ»ÒÈ ÅÉËÅÍÒÐÏÍÅÒÁÉ ¾-
ÍÎ ÑÒÉÕ Ñ×ÍÓ¼ËÅÕ. ÉÎ Ñ×ÇËÅËÐÉ»ÍÁ, ÁÐËŽÒÁÉ ÑÒÈÍ ÅÊ»ÒÁÑÈ ËÁ;ÍÔÍ Ñ×ÇËÅËÐÉ»ÍÔÍ
Ñ×ÍÓÈËÏÍ: ÒÈÕ ÅÍÉË¼Õ ÀÂÁÑÈÕ ÁÑÏÍ ËÁÉ £ÎнÎ× (‘GATT’),
4
ÒÈÕ ÀÂÁÑÈÕ ÇÉÁ
ÒÎͳÐÒȣͻÐÇÅÉÁÕ (‘ECT’)
5
ËÁÉ ÎÐÉÑ»ÍÔÍÑ×ÍÓÈËÏÍÑÖÅÒÉËÅ Ñ×ÇËÅËÐÉ»ÍÎ×Õ ÁÇÔ-
ÇÎÀÕ: ¾ÔÕ, È ÑׯÔͽÁ ÅÒÁÊÀ ÒÈÕ ÈÎËÐÁÒ½ÁÕ ÒÈÕ ¡×ÑÒнÁÕ, ÒÈÕ ÈÎËÐÁÒ½ÁÕ ÒÈÕ
¢Î×ÌÇÁнÁÕ, ÒÈÕ ÈÎËÐÁÒ½ÁÕ ÒÈÕ ¯×ÇÇÁнÁÕ, ÒÈÕ °Î×ÁͽÁÕ ËÁÉ ÒÈÕ ÈÎËÐÁÒ½ÁÕ ÒÈÕ
±Î×Ð˽ÁÕ ÑÖÅÒÉË Å ÒÎÍ ÁÇÔǾNabucco (×ÍÓ¼ËÈ ÇÉÁ ÒÎÍ ÁÇÔǾNabucco), È ÎνÁ
×ÅÇÐÆÈÑÒÉÕ 13 ¦Î×̽Î×2009 ËÁÉ È ×ÆÔͽÁÅÒÁÊÀ ÒÈÕÈÎËÐÁÒ½ÁÕ ÒÈÕ¡ÌÂÁͽÁÕ,
* Lecturer, UniversityCollege London, Faculty of Laws (PhD, LLM, UniversityCollege London, LLM, £ÓÍÉ˾
ËÁɧÁÎÄÉÑÒÐÉÁ˾ÁÍÅÉÑÒ¼ÉΡÓÈÍÏÍ):
1. ÉÁ ÅËÒÅͼÁÍÌ×ÑÈÎÌ×ÐÉÓÔÍ Ò»ÒÎÉÔÍ Ñ×ÍÓÈËÏÍ ËÁÉ ÒÈÕ ÑÖ»ÑÈÕ ÒÎ×Õ Å ÒÎĽËÁÉÎ Å×ÓÀÍÈÕ ËÐÁÒÏÍ,
ÂÌ.
D. A
ZARIA
,
Transit of Energy via Pipelines in International Law: Treaties and Countermeasures
(OxfordUniversityPress: forthcoming2014).
2. ¢Ì. ÇÉÁ ÁÐÄÅÉÇÁ,Model Host-Governmental Agreement prepared under the auspices of the Energy
CharterSecretariat:
3. ¢Ì. ÇÅÍÉË,
R
EDGWELL
, ‘Contractual andTreatyArrangementsSupportingLargeEuropeanTransboundary
Pipeline Projects: Can Adequate Human Rights and Environmental Protection be Secured?’, in
M.M.
R
OGGENKAMP
et al.
,
EnergyNetworks and the Law: Innovative Solutions inChangingMarkets
(2012),
ÑÅÌ. 102.
4.
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, Annex IA to the Agreement establishing theWorld Trade
Organization
, 1867UNTS3.
5. TheEnergyCharter Treaty (withannexes) (done in Lisbon17December 1994, entered into force16April
1998) 2080UNTS 95, as amendedby the Final Act of the International Conference andDecisionby the
EnergyCharter Conference in respect of theAmendment to the Trade-Related Provisions of the Energy
Charter Treaty, Annex 1 (adopted on 24 April 1998, entered in force 21 January 2010) in
The Energy
CharterTreatyandRelatedDocuments
, 2004, ÑÅÌ. 167-207.