£®£°£¦¡: ¦§±²¡&²¯¯¨£
8
. ¡¤¡°¦¡
ÅÀÒÅÐÎÍ
, Ò¾ÑÎ ÒÎ ÐÓÐÎV ÒÈÕ GATT ËÁÉ ÒÎ ÐÓÐÎ 7 ÒÈÕ ECT ÅÐÉÌÁÂÍÎ×Í ÒÎ »ÐÁ-
ÑÁ Á¾ ÉÁ ÇÅÔÇÐÁÆÉ˼ ÅÐÉÎÖ¼ ÒÔÍ Ñ×ÂÁÌÌλÍÔÍ ÅÐÏÍ, ÅÆ¾ÑÎÍ ÒÎ ËÐÒÎÕ ÄÉ»-
ÌÅ×ÑÈÕ ËÁÉ »ÍÁ ÌÌÎ ËÐÒÎÕ (ËÐÒÎÕ ÐλÌÅ×ÑÈÕ ¼ ÐÎÎÐÉÑÎÀ) ŽÍÁÉ Ñ×ÂÁÌ̾ÅÍÁ
»ÐÈ. ÅÍÁÁÉÒŽÒÁÉ ¾ÌÁ ÒÁËÐÒÈÎ×Ñ×ÅÒ»ÖÎ×ÍÑÒÈÍ ËÁÒÑÒÁÑÈÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈÕ ÍÁ ŽÍÁÉ
Ñ×ÂÁÌ̾ÅÍÁ»ÐÈÐÎËÅÉ»ÍÎ× ÒλÐÁÑÁÍÁÖÁÐÁËÒÈÐÉÑÒŽÔÕÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈ
.
20
±Ð½ÒÎÍ
, ËÁÉ ÎÉ ÄÀÎÎÐÉÑν ËÁÌÀÒÎ×Í ÒÈÍ ÅнÒÔÑȾÎ×ÈÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈÁÆÎÐÑÒÎ ½ÄÉÎ
ËÐÒÎÕ ÐλÌÅ×ÑÈÕ ËÁÉ ÐÎÎÐÉÑÎÀ. ÉÁÁÐÄÅÉÇÁ, ÒÈÍÅнÒÔÑÈ ÒÈÕ ÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈÕÆ×-
ÑÉËÎÀÁÅнÎ×Î×ÐλÐÖÅÒÁÉ Á¾ ÒȰÔѽÁ»ÑÔ ÒÈÕÉÓÎ×ÁͽÁÕ ËÁÉ ÐÎÎнØÅÒÁÉ ÇÉÁ ÒÎ
§Á̽ÍÉÍÇËÐÁÍÒ, ÅÐÉÎÖ¼Î×ÂнÑËÅÒÁÉ ×¾ ÒÈÍË×ÐÉÁÐÖ½Á ÒÈÕ°ÔѽÁÕ.
£½ÍÁÉ Å½ÑÈÕ ÑÈÁÍÒÉ˾ ÍÁ ÄÉÅ×ËÐÉÍÉÑÒŽ ¾ÒÉ È ECT ÅÆÁоØÅÒÁÉ ÑÒÈ ÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈ »-
ÑÔ²ÎÄÎÏͨÅÒÁÆÎÐÕ £Í»ÐÇÅÉÁÕ, Î× ÎнØÎÍÒÁÉ ÑÒδÐÓÐÎ 7(10) ÒÈÕ ECT, ÅÍÏ ÒÎ
´ÐÓÐÎV ÒÈÕ GATT ÄÅ ÄÉÅ×ËÐÉͽØÅÉ ÁÍ ÅÆÁоØÅÒÁÉ ÑÅ ÑÖ»ÑÈÅ ÒÎ×Õ ÁÇÔÇÎÀÕ. ¬ÑÒ¾ÑÎ,
ÈÄÉÒÁÊÈÄÅÍ ÁÁÇÎÐÅÀÅÉ Á×Ò¼ ÒÈÍ ÅÆÁÐÎǼ ËÁÉ Ñ×ÍÅÏÕ Å½ÍÁÉ Ä×ÍÁÒ¾ ÍÁ ÉÑÖ×ÐÉÑÒŽ
ËÁÍŽվÒÉ ÅÆÁоØÅÒÁÉ ÑÅÑÖ»ÑÈÅ ÒÈÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈ»ÑÔÁÇÔÇÏÍÁÅнÎ×ËÁÉ ÅÒÐÅÌÁ½Î×.
21
B.
²ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÉÕ ×ÅÐÉÆÎÐÕ ËÁÉ ²ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÉÕ¡ÎÒÅÌ»ÑÁÒÎÕ
¯É Ñ×ÍÓ¼ËÅÕ Î× ÄÈÉÎ×ÐÇÎÀÍ ×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÉÕ ÑÖÅÒÉË Å ÒÈ ÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈ ÅÍ»ÐÇÅÉÁÕ Å½ÒÅ
ÖÐÈÑÉÎÎÉÎÀÍ ¾ÐÎ×Õ ¾ÔÕ «ÅÌÅ×ÓÅнÁÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈÕ », «ÅÌÅÀÓÅÐÈÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈ», «ÁÐÖ¼ ÒÈÕ
ÅÌÅ×ÓÅнÁÕ ÒÈÕÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈÕ», ¼ÄÅÍËÍÎ×ÍËÁ½ÁÁÍÁÆÎÐÑÅ«ÄÉËÁ½ÔÁ»¼«ÅÌÅ×ÓÅнÁ»,
¾ÒÁÍÁÁÉÒÎÀÍÁ¾ ÒÁËÐÒÈÍÁ ÅÉÒлÃÎ×Í ÒÈÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈ.¥ »ÍÍÎÉÁ ÅÌÅ×ÓÅнÁÁÍÁÆ»ÐÅÒÁÉ
Ë×нÔÕ ÑÅ «ÁÎÖ¼»: ÑÒÎÑÅÂÁѾ ËÁÉ ÒÈÈÁОÄÉÑÈ ÒÈÕ ÅÌÅ×ÓÅнÁÕ. ÉÁÁÐÄÅÉÇ-
Á, È ÅÌÅ×ÓÅнÁ ÒÈÕ ÁÍÎÉËÒ¼Õ ÓÌÁÑÑÁÕ.
22
ÅÁÍÒ½ÓÅÑÈÅ ÒÈÍ«ÅÌÅ×ÓÅнÁ», È »ÍÍÎÉÁ«ÄÉ-
ËÁ½ÔÁ»ÅÐÉÌÁÂÍÅÉ ¾ÖÉ ¾ÍÎ ÒÈÍ ÁÎÖ¼Á¾ ËÎÉÁÑ×ÅÐÉÆÎÐ, ÁÌÌ ËÁÉ ÒÈÓÅÒÉ-
˼ Ñ×ÅÐÉÆÎÐ: ×ÎÖлÔÑÈ ÍÁ ÌÂÅÉ ÒÎ ËÐÒÎÕ ÁÎÒÅÌÅÑÁÒÉË »ÒÐÁ ÐÎËÅÉ»ÍÎ×
ÍÁÅÊÁÑÆÁ̽ÑÅÉ ÒÈÍÁ¾ÌÁ×ÑÈ ÒÎ×ÄÉËÁÉÏÁÒÎÕÁ¾»ÍÁÌÌÎËÐÒÎÕ¼»ÍÁ ÒнÒλÐÎÕ.
23
20.
P
ANEL
R
EPORT
,
Colombia - Indicative Prices and Restrictions on Ports of Entry
, WT/DS366/R and
Corr.1, adopted 20May 2009, ÁÐÁ. 7.401-7.402; WTO Secretariat,
Article V of GATT 1994 - Scope
andApplication
, TN/TF/W2, 12 January 2005, ÑÅÌ. 2. Contra (ÐÉÍ Á¾ ÒÈÍ ×ÉÎÓ»ÒÈÑÈ ÒÈÕ Á¾ÆÁÑÈÕ
Colombia - Indicative Prices and Restrictions on Ports of Entry
):
J.H. J
ACKSON
,
World Trade and
the Law of GATT: a Legal Analysis of theGeneral Agreement on Tariffs and Trade
, (Charlottesville,
Virginia: TheMichie Cie, 1969), ÑÅÌ. 506-507;
WTO Rules Applying under the Energy Charter Treaty,
(Brussels: Energy Charter Secretariat, 2001), ÑÅÌ. 34;
R.R. C
HURCHILL
and
A.V. L
OWE
,
The Law of the
Sea
, (Yonkers, New York: Juris Publishing; Manchester: Manchester University Press, 3rd ed., 1999)
ÑÅÌ. 441;
R.K. B
HALA
,
ModernGATT Law, A Treatise on theAgreement on Tariffs and Trade
, (London:
Sweet&Maxwell, 2005), ÑÅÌ. 472.
21. ÉÁ ÅËÒÅͼ ÁÍÌ×ÑÈ ËÁÉ ÅÐÈÍŽÁ ÒÈÕ ÄÉÒÁÊÈÕ ÑÅ ÑÖ»ÑÈ Å Á×Ò¾ ÒÎ Ó»Á, ÂÌ.
D. A
ZARIA
,
Transit of
Energy via Pipelines in International Law: Treaties and Countermeasures
(Oxford University Press:
forthcoming2014).
22.
D.R. R
OTHWELL
and
T. S
TEPHENS
,
The International Lawof theSea
, (Oxford:Hart, 2010), ÑÅÌ. 145-158;
R.R. C
HURCHILL
and
A.V. L
OWE
,
The Lawof theSea
, (Yonkers, NewYork: Juris Publishing;Manchester:
Manchester University Press, 3rd ed., 1999) ÑÅÌ. 203-208;
R.J. D
UPUY
and
D. V
IGNES
, (eds.),
A
Handbookon theNewLawof theSea
,Vol. II, (Dordrecht:Nijhoff, 1991), ÑÅÌ. 383-400.
23. ÉÁÁÐÄÅÉÇÁÑÅ ÑÖ»ÑÈÅ ÒÁÄÉËÁÉÏÁÒÁ ÒÎ×ÁÍÓÐÏÎ×:
P. A
LSTON
and
R. G
OODMAN
,
International
HumanRights
, (Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress, 2012), ÑÅÌ. 181-182.