ÉÅÓͼĽËÒ×Á ÅÍ»ÐÇÅÉÁÕ ËÁÉ ÐÔÒÎÇÅÍÅ½Õ Ñ×ÂÁÒÉË»Õ ×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÉÕ ËÐÁÒÏÍ
. ¡¤¡°¦¡
9
Å ËÓÅ ÅнÒÔÑÈ, È ×ÎÖлÔÑÈ Á×Ò¼ ÂÁÐÀÍÅÉ ÒÎ ËÐÒÎÕ ÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈÕ ÍÁ Ñ×ÅÐÉÆÅÐ-
ÓŽ Å »ÍÁÑ×ÇËÅËÐÉ»ÍÎ ÒоÎÐÎÕ »ÍÁÌÌÎ×ÎËŽÅÍÎ ÒÎ×ÄÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ ÄÉËÁ½Î×. ¡×Ò¾
Î× ÁÌÌØÅÉ Å½ÍÁÉ È Ñ×ÅÐÉÆÎÐ Î× ÁÁÉÒŽ È ×ÎÖлÔÑÈ: ÎÐŽ ÍÁ ŽÍÁÉ ÓÅÒÉ˼ ¼
ÁÐÍÈÒÉ˼¼ËÁÉ ÒÁÄÀÎ.¥ÁÐÁ½ÁÑÈ ÒÈÕ×ÎÖлÔÑÈÕ ÍÁÁ»ÖÅÉ ÒÎËÐÒÎÕÁ¾ÁÐÅÂ-
ÑÅÉÕ ÑÒÈÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈ ÅÍ»ÐÇÅÉÁÕ ¼ÈÁÐÁ½ÁÑÈ ÒÈÕ ×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÔÕ ÍÁ ÌÈÆÓÎÀÍÓÅÒÉË»ÒÐÁ
ÇÉÁ ÒÈÍ ÅÊÁÑÆÌÉÑÈ (¼ ÒÈÄÉÅ×˾Ì×ÍÑÈ) ÒÈÕÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈÕ ÅÍÅÐÇÎÎÉŽ ÒÈÄÉÅÓͼ Å×ÓÀÍÈ ÒÎ×
ËÐÒÎ×Õ ÄÉ»ÌÅ×ÑÈÕ, ËÁÉ ÄÈÉÎ×ÐÇŽ »ÍÁ Ñ×ÍÁ˾ÌÎ×ÓÎ ÄÉËÁ½ÔÁ ÁÎØÈÉÏÑÅÔÕ ÇÉÁ ÒÎ
ËÐÒÎÕÎ××»ÑÒÈÂÌÂÈ.
ÒÎ ÄÉÅÓÍ»Õ Ä½ËÁÉΠǽÍÅÒÁÉ ÄÉËÐÉÑÈ ÅÒÁÊÀ ÒÔÍ ×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÔÍ Ñ×ÅÐÉÆÎÐÕ ËÁÉ ÒÔÍ
×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÔÍÁÎÒÅÌ»ÑÁÒÎÕÑÅÑÖ»ÑÈÅ ÒÉÕÐÔÒÎÇÅÍŽÕ×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÉÕ. ¡×Ò¼ÈÄÉËÐÉ-
ÑÈ ÎÐŽ ÍÁ ÂÎÈÓ¼ÑÅÉ ÑÒÎÍ ÅÍÒÎÉѾ ÒÎ× ÏÕ ËÁÉ ¾ÒÅ ×¼ÐÊÅ ÁÐÁ½ÁÑÈ ÒÈÕ ×Î-
ÖлÔÑÈÕ.
¯É ×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÉÕ ÁÎÒÅÌ»ÑÁÒÎÕ ×ÎÖÐÅÏÍÎ×Í ÒÈÍ Å½ÒÅ×ÊÈ ÒÎ× ÁÎÒÅÌ»ÑÁÒÎÕ, ÁÌÌ
ÁƼÍÎ×ÍÑÒÁËÐÒÈ ÒÈÄÉÁËÐÉÒÉ˼ Å×Ö»ÐÅÉÁÔÕ ÐÎÕ ÒÈÍ ÅÉÌÎǼ ÒÔÍ»ÑÔÍÅ ÒÁÎνÁ
ÓÁ ÅÉÒÅ×ÖÓŽ Á×Ò¾ ÒÎÁÎÒ»ÌÅÑÁ.¬ÑÒ¾ÑÎ, ÒÁ»ÑÁÎ× ÒÎËÐÒÎÕÓÁ ÅÉÌ»ÊÅÉ Ð»ÅÉ ÍÁ
ŽÍÁÉ ÅÁÐ˼ ÇÉÁ ÒÈÍ ÉËÁÍÎνÈÑÈ ÒÈÕ ×ÎÖлÔÑÈÕ.
24
¡ÍÒ½ÓÅÒÁ, ½Á×ÎÖлÔÑÈÑ×Å-
ÐÉÆÎÐÕ ×ÎÖÐÅÏÍÅÉ ÒÎ ËÐÒÎÕ ÍÁ Ñ×ÅÐÉÆ»ÐÅÒÁÉ Å »ÍÁÍ ÎÐÉÑ»ÍÎ ÒоÎ: ÒÁ ËÐÒÈ
ÄÅÍ Å½ÍÁÉ ×ÎÖÐÅÔ»ÍÁÍÁ ÅÉÒÀÖÎ×Í »ÍÁÑ×ÇËÅËÐÉ»ÍÎÁÎÒ»ÌÅÑÁ, ÌÌÎÁ¾ ÒÎÍÁÑ×-
ÅÐÉÆÅÐÓÎÀÍÅ »ÍÁÑ×ÇËÅËÐÉ»ÍÎ ÒоÎ.
25
¯Combacau ÅÉÑÈÁ½ÍÅÉ ¾ÒÉ ½Á×ÎÖлÔ-
ÑÈÑ×ÅÐÉÆÎÐÕ ÁÎÒÅÌŽ ×ÎÖлÔÑÈ
‘de s'efforcer’
: ×ÎÖлÔÑÈ ÍÁÐÎÑÁÓ¼ÑÅÉ ÒÎ
ËÐÒÎÕÍÁÐÁÇÁÒÎÎɼÑÅÉ »ÍÁÑ×ÇËÅËÐÉ»ÍÎÁÎÒ»ÌÅÑÁ.
26
¥ £ÉÒÐμÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ ÉËÁ½Î× (‘£’) ÒÔÍ¥ÍÔ»ÍÔÍ £ÓÍÏÍ (‘¥£’) ÑÒÉÕ ÅÐÇÁѽÅÕ ÒÈÕ ÇÉÁ
ÒÈÄÉÅÓͼ Å×ÓÀÍÈ ÒÔÍ ËÐÁÒÏÍ Å½ÖÅ ÁÐÖÉË×ÉÎÓÅÒ¼ÑÅÉ ÑÅ ÐÏÒÈ ÁÍÇÍÔÑÈ ÒнÁ ÐÓÐÁ
ÑÖÅÒÉËÅ ÒÉÕ×ÎÖÐÅÏÑÅÉÕÑ×ÅÐÉÆÎÐÕ, ÁÎÒÅÌ»ÑÁÒÎÕ ËÁÉ Ð¾ÌÈÃÈÕ.¬ÑÒ¾ÑÎ, Á×Ò
ÒÁ ÐÓÐÁ ÄÅÍ Ñ×ÅÐÉ̼ÆÓÈÑÁÍ ÑÒÎ ÒÅÌÉ˾ ÑÖ»ÄÉÎ ÒÔÍ ÐÓÐÔÍ ÇÉÁ ÒÈ ÄÉÅÓͼ Å×ÓÀÍÈ
ÒÔÍ ËÐÁÒÏÍ, ÄÅÄλÍÎ× ¾ÒÉ ÑÖÅÒ½ØÎÍÒÁÉ Å ÒÎ ÅÐÉÅÖ¾ÅÍÎ ÒÔÍ ÐÔÒÎÇÅÍÏÍ ËÁ;ÍÔÍ,
ÁÐÅ ÒÎ×ÕËÁ;ÍÅÕ ÒÎ×ÄÉÅÓÍÎÀÕ Å×ÓÀÍÈÕ.
27
24.
Iran v. United States
, AwardN.590-A15(IV)/A24-FT, 28December 1998, ÁÐÁ. 95. £½ÑÈÕ: Text of the
draft articles on responsibility of States for internationallywrongful actswith commentaries thereto,
Report of theCommission to theGeneral Assembly on thework of its fifty-third session, YbILC 2001-
II, ÑÅÌ. 57, ÁÐÁ. 12; Special RapporteurCrawford,
SecondReportonStateResponsibility
,A/CN.4/498,
17March1999, ÁÐÁ. 60-68.
25. ¥ÐÏÒÈ ÒÁÊÉ;ÈÑÈ ÒÎ×£ÉÄÉËÎÀ£ÉÑÈÇÈÒ¼RobertoAgo¼ÒÁÍÄÉÁÅÒÐÉËÁÍÒ½ÓÅÒÈÁ¾Á×Ò¼ ÒÈÄÉËÐÉÑÈ,
ËÁÉ ÁÍÒÉÅÒÔ½ÑÒÈËÅ Å ÅÍÄÎÉÁÑÎÀÕ. Special Rapporteur Ago, SixthReport on State Responsibility, A/
CN.4/302andAdd.1-3, ILCYB, 1977-II, ÑÅÌ. 4-20.
26.
J.C
OMBACAU
,ObligationsdeRésultatetObligationsdeComportement:QuelquesQuestionsetpasde
Réponse, in
D. B
ARDONNET
,
Mélanges offerts à Paul Reuter: le droit international: unité et diversité
,
(Paris: Pedone, 1981), ÑÅÌ. 202.
27. Text of thedraft articles on responsibility of States for internationallywrongful actswith commentar-
ies thereto, Report of theCommission to theGeneral Assembly on thework of its fifty-third session,
YbILC2001-II, ÑÅÌ. 56, ÁÐÁ. 11.